Alright, I've got a good enough idea where we're going with this visual novel, so I'm going to officially end our first round of polling. Here are the results.
Now for the moment you've all been waiting for, the five dateable girls will be:
Yang Xiao Long from RWBY
Kari from Digimon Season 2
Erza Scarlet from Fairy Tail
Leafa from Sword Art Online
Sasha Braus from Attack on Titan
A big thanks to everyone who voted and look forward to a few of the first art assets coming out this week.